Attorney Michael de Broglio on: South Africa, Law, Politics, Attorneys, Sport, Photography, Technology, Gadgets, Media, Crime, Road Accidents Fund, Divorce, Maintenance, Personal Injury, Medical Negligence
Home - Recent Entries

Taking away the iPhone and taking away the iPad

I read a recent article in The Atlantic magazine, and it featured an article written by an author whose new book is called iGen.  She says that is her name for people born after 2005, and it all coincides with 2012, at which time 50% of the population all had phones.  I think what she says though relates to many who had phones before that and who are mostly aged about 16 to 20 now.

The article goes on to detail how today’s teenagers are in fact unhappier than ever before.  Usage of devices is up, suicide rates are up and everything else is down, including in particular, sleep.

It has become all too easy for modern parents to give their little darling an iPhone, possibly even an iPad as well as a computer and the children are running back and forth from one device to another.  They don’t play outside very much anymore, they seldom actually meet with their friends, and they lie in bed late at night messaging people back and forth every day.  They have accounts on Instagram, they try to keep SnapChat streaks going and they are committing suicide in higher numbers than ever before.  Incidentally, suicide numbers reduce considerably when somebody plays sport and goes to church.  The main thrust of the article is that today’s teenagers are not happier because of the devices their parents are giving them.  They are far less happy than ever before.  Their lives are being spent on these little screens, and girls in particular are getting bullied by other girls and ostracised on social media.  It is a mistake that parents are making, and I do hope that the anti-cell phone movement grows.  There are certainly already signs that more astute parents don’t give their children devices – let’s not forget that the man who was in charge of Apple, Steve Jobs, did not allow his children to have devices – they could not have iPhones or iPads.  His company simply sold them to your children.  

He knew how bad they were, he could see their negative effects and his company has presided over making money out of you, but he certainly did not let his own children have such devices.  Remember that when your child begs and pressurises you for a cell phone, start reading up on this topic because it is actually the weaker and worse parents who are giving in to this with all sorts of excuses such as they spend a lot of time at work or their child needs it to learn, etc, etc.  Your child does not need an IPad or iPhone to learn anything unless you want him or her to become skilled at computer games and online chat!  The children themselves are not happier for it, no matter what they tell you in order for you to pay to get them that device and that device ends up replacing you as parents and ruling their lives and ends up being the conduit for the bullying of your child.  Think carefully before you go down that road and also try and think more critically.  Stop making and looking for excuses for the easy way out when it comes to having kids.  It is so easy to simply, as a grandparent or as a parent, give a device and chase the child off into another room to play with the device – but are you really doing your bit when you behave like that?  The early feedback, the early statistics and indicators on the current generation would suggest that you will bring up a depressed and socially inept loser if you take the easy route.  I personally think that in about 10 to 15 years’ time most parents in developed nations will ban their children from having such devices or limit them to no more than 30 minutes a day on the devices.  I guess then, just like with the cigarette and sugar companies, those companies will have to start targeting the poor, the developing nations and start pumping cheaper versions of their products into Africa and elsewhere in much bigger numbers. 

Posted by Michael de Broglio on Friday 13-Oct-17 Share on Facebook   Tweet It

Post a Comment
Comments

Cornelie  said:
on Thursday 02-Nov-17 09:27 AM
As I remember the days when we were young we had so much fun outside we did not even knew then about phones and ipads etc whish our kids could do what we have done as kids.

Sinead  said:
on Wednesday 01-Nov-17 11:56 AM
This is an interesting read and I feel it's both true and somewhat sad. This new generation is doomed. Technology is everything to them. They don't even know how to have fun anymore. On the other hand, they are becoming a lot more tech savvy so they can grow up to build even better technological products... :)
Cyber bullying is also what is killing our youth and no one sees it...
I had a phone in my late years of primary school but it was strictly for emergencies. I didn't have anything fancy. This could also be due to the fact that we didn't have Facebook and/or Instagram yet.

Liz  said:
on Monday 30-Oct-17 08:30 AM
It is so apparent that cellphones and other devices are the main reason for our unhappy and depressed generation. The constant comparing of your life to the seemingly perfect life of others is a sure way of ensuring you are never content. Children should be children and I don't believe they should be allowed to have access to these devices until an appropriate age.

patrick  said:
on Friday 27-Oct-17 04:55 PM
gargets are really bad for our kids. my worry is that very soon developing countries will be burdened with a bigger health bill related to obersity .Nothing replaces running around.

joyce  said:
on Friday 27-Oct-17 04:45 PM
I think taking away iPhone and or iPad the child can still get it from friends, I think it would be better when explained to them the dangers of using the devices

Prishani  said:
on Friday 27-Oct-17 08:49 AM
This is an interesting topic and I'm sure parents all over the world are stuck with deciding what to do, this blog makes it very clear, and as a parent you would have to way up the positives and the negatives of having all these devices! Many schools have also introduced using these products, this makes it so much harder for a parent!

brumilde  said:
on Friday 27-Oct-17 08:10 AM
My 3 year old uses my old phone, he mostly streams youtube, songs and kiddies videos. But i still read to him everynight and he would prefer to play outside if he could. but the best way to punish him is by taking away the phone. i am so shocked to see how much my 3 year old can do on the phone already. i wonder what the next generation will experience

Natasha   said:
on Tuesday 24-Oct-17 07:30 AM
In todays life every child has a phone or an ipad of some sort my godchild of 5 has one I think in a way its a good thing seeing that they learn a lot and get to know technology but on the other hand he never goes outside to play so it goes two ways children need to play outside and get dirty and fresh air.

Jadine E  said:
on Monday 23-Oct-17 07:13 AM
Children also need to know that not only does the phone distract them but as it is quite a pricey phone it puts their lives at risk when walking to nearby shops and being so into the phone that you are not aware of the danger/ what's happening around you

Nicky  said:
on Friday 20-Oct-17 04:36 PM
My eldest daughter has a tablet and we were conflicted on whether she should use it when she received it as a gift. We have decided to let her use it but with rules-she can only use it over the weekend and we regularly monitor her tablet just to make sure that her safety will not be compromised. I am very selective about what I put up on Whatspp(the only social media app I have)and I try to instill the same with my daughter-no profile pictures of herself or family; very limited contacts etc. The one thing that does annoy me with her tablet us is that she sometimes gets so busy with a game that she just ignores what's happening around he-that's usually when she gets reprimanded and her tablet gets taken away. I cannot stand it when people (children and adults) are oblivious to what's happening around them because they're too busy on their phones-we miss out so much of what's happening around us because of phones.

Liesl  said:
on Wednesday 18-Oct-17 08:40 AM
This subject often comes up in conversations. When I was child we literally played outside the entire day and was only called into the house for lunch. When we moved to South Africa and didn't have a garden the size we were used to we played in the street, hop scotch; cricket; rode our bicycles etc and we were safe. The thing is in today's society we cannot allow our children to play outside like we used to, it's not safe for them and unless you have a home with a proper garden for them to play in, it becomes difficult. I have also found that most townhouse complexes don't like families to move in with small children as they say kids are noisy - but where must the children go to be just be children. When my sister's daughter went to high school it was compulsory for her to have an iPad as they do all their work on that, so that is how the children are being bred, no more writing out a 3 page essay or making of notes for your exam etc. Technology is great but it definitely has a down side to it as well

Jessica Apfel   said:
on Tuesday 17-Oct-17 04:14 PM
It is quite sad that teenagers are so much more unhappy - their lives are constantly in the public eye and they feel as if they have to live up to public satisfaction. It shouldn't be like that, however we cannot deny the electronic age that we live in! Cyber bullying is a tragic thing and is far too easy for teenagers to engage in it - without seeing first hand how it actually affects the child on the other side. It reduces a large degree of accountability.

Angelique Jurgens  said:
on Tuesday 17-Oct-17 03:15 PM
It will be so interesting to see how parents are able to work around this - in this day and age it is almost impossible for ones child not to have a phone. The effort would come in parents parenting more by having strict rules in place to ensure children do not get addicted to the internet and be a child by playing outside! I also understand perhaps some parents want peace and quiet and often that means handing over the phone. Very interesting indeed.

Thabitha  said:
on Tuesday 17-Oct-17 07:49 AM
I don't like social media, people are being scrutinized there so what more to young girls and boys. I will not give my kids those devices for he sake of their happiness.

Jadine Richards  said:
on Monday 16-Oct-17 03:15 PM
I agree that children shouldn't be raised by devices however it is a bit of a catch 22 in today's society. Many schools are going paperless leaving parents with no choice but to buy their children an iPad. Children who don't have access to these devices are then made to be social pariah's. Another thing is that these new apps provide great educational benefits for young children. Its a nice idea to have the kids be outdoors and being one with nature but it is just not the way of the times.

Angelique P  said:
on Monday 16-Oct-17 09:28 AM
This is an excellent blog. I wish people with children can be more aware of the danger of giving a phone to the child to keep them busy. It’s really so sad to see that most children will rather play on their parents phones than to play outside. I remember when I was a child I loved being outside It was difficult to get me inside at nights. I think it’s a good idea to restrict children to certain time periods on their phones. I really hope the day that I have children that I will try my best to keep them away from social media.

Helen  said:
on Monday 16-Oct-17 08:56 AM
This is very good article to read and I am fully agree that start giving in kid's hands devices will lead to terrible outcomes in their future. There was an article on the Cart Blanch one day about giving tablets to 2-5 year old kids, where parents thinks
that doing this is very good for educational purposes, but mean time psychologists were confirming that these kids are slow developing, are very bad in socializing with other kids, and as well slow learners!

Ashleigh  said:
on Monday 16-Oct-17 08:33 AM
The worst mistake a parent could make is allowing children to have technology. I would suggest from experience that you should hold out until they16 years old and above. Children do not want to study after school now that they have these devices. Cyber bullying happens on these devices as well. But due to my error, I use it as a tool against my kids. If my kids don't bring home good marks, they have their devices taken away for a whole term and until they bring home good marks. They cannot live without their phones now and hate being grounded so it works. :) But I still suggest never allowing a child to grow up with the phones, tablets, etc... It actually has a huge impact on various things in their lives. Things we never ever went through while we were growing up without technology.

Michelle  said:
on Monday 16-Oct-17 07:42 AM
This is actually a very complicated topic to comment on. I do agree that devices have an influence on how children today function, they struggle more to study etc. Children should have a balanced life. Unfortunately you cannot keep them away completely from technology and if you try they will only explore such at their friends’ houses.

Nikita  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 04:30 PM
I was fortunate enough to have grown up on a farm and having the luxury of spending my play time in trees or with animals. My mother was always very strict about playing outside and being a child. We were not allowed to lay in our rooms or interfere with the adults we had to go play outside. Some of my fondest memories are of us children playing outside building forts or baking mud biscuits. I hope that my children can experience the same some day. I agree that children should not be given these devices to play with. I also read an article some time back about how children are struggling with copying words down from a board in school because they are so used to being on a cellphone. The problem is that society has changed and I suppose that some parents will argue that it is for safety reasons that they give their child a phone.

Jolene   said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 03:29 PM
I don’t think a child should have a phone, there is so many risks and you cannot always control what they do and who they chat with. I think for some parents it is quite hard not to allow their children to play on phones or tablets when they themselves are using them all the time.

Daniella  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 11:10 AM
Cyber bullying is a huge problem in today's society, there is this cloak of anonymity where people feel as though they can say what ever they want and not have any consequences . They also don't see the person they bullying on social media as a person with feeling, they see them as a profile, and lets be real kids can be mean.
With regards with kids have iPhones and iPads at a young age they going to end up being socially awkward, depressed and living in your basement long into their adulthood. Once they get to the age 13 I feel like they would need a phone though so that as a parent you can contact them and check up on them.

Nicolle  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 09:50 AM
"Researchers warned that using a tablet or smartphone to divert a child’s attention could be detrimental to “their social-emotional development”. - The Guardian

Mathilda  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 09:41 AM
I can remember when I was still a kid we played outside until the street lights came on, and today I can only thank my parents that they did not allow me to have a phone until I turned 13, let me tell you though I could literally make calls and send messages, no colour screen no internet but hey I had a phone and was happy lol

And I will do the same with my children one day

Nina  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 09:21 AM
These days I think it is extremely difficult to manage these type of things as it is becomming such a big part of our everyday lives. I would definitely not want to give my children a device of their own before high school. Hopefully I will stick to that one day and not give in.

Bianca R  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 08:58 AM
I must be honest, I had an extremely happy childhood without any technology! We played, physically played, we spent our time swimming, playing hide and seek, running, and playing in the park etc, I wouldn't change that for a childhood filled with technology! I see small children from the age of 10 walking around with the same phone as me as well as an endless amounts of iPad's and tablets, never mind the gaming consoles they all have. I am not sure if parents these days are too scared to actually allow their children to play outside due to kidnappings etc but it has become extremely sad to see no children outside, all stuck behind devices or in front of a TV..... My step child who is now 13, is an outdoor fanatic and would rather be flying planes, riding motorbikes or playing in the dirt than sitting in front of any device, I suppose it also depends on the upbringing of the child. My youngest godson, who is almost 3, can navigate his way through a Samsung or iPhone like a piece of cake. I just think that the children are missing a certain element of interaction with other beings and that could be causing the depression, at the end of the day, I don't believe we are meant to function too well being run by technology.

Melissa van Tellingen  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 08:42 AM
I will never allow my kids to have Phones or IPads before they are 13 or so. I didn't have these things when I grew up an I turned out just fine. I was part of a generation who still played outside in the rain and the mud and kids today don't know what it is. I think that it's unfair towards our children if you allow it. Just my opinion.

Jessica M  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 08:28 AM
I must say I will not give my child a sim car for their tablet, they also are limited to how much time they allowed to play on them. My one son loves games, so I will get him a handheld game console for Christmas, I don't want them on the internet or chatting to "friends" who bring them down and make them feel horrible. I prefer buying my kids arts and crafts or toys because then they don't spend much time on their tablets. I also have now limited myself to my cell phone, when I get home I do not look at it until my children are asleep. You can't say to them they can't if you are.

Bianca N  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 08:18 AM
I think that children should still play outside and learn to socialize with people face to face. If they only learn to play on devices from a young age they will not develop the necessary social skills for when they need to go out into the world and work, etc. They will not be able to build meaningful relationships if they only interact through a little screen from their couch.

Sarah  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 08:09 AM
I fully agree that a child should be a child, play outside with dirt etc. My son is only two right now , he is still to young for I Pad etc. When your child is always on a device how is she or he going to interact with people? They wont development proper social skills.

Clare  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 07:51 AM
First of all I hate phones I don't like them my son has a Tablet but the only thing he can do on the Tablet is Play a Game or Watch a Movie and that is when we travel to my In-laws that live in the Free State other then That my son plays outside, colors in his book or plays with his Toys. He does watch TV if he feels like it but that Is watching with one eye and playing with the other eye.. I don't believe that Kids from 0 - 16 Should have a phone but because of the life people live children get teased and bullied because they don't have a phone because that how kids are they are horrible.. I will only let my son have his Tablet under my supervision other then that he can go play outside in the yard to learn how to be a child. Technology is not always the best thing in life the small things in Life are Free and they are the best things.

david  said:
on Friday 13-Oct-17 07:18 AM
there was a show on 702 the other day on the subject.
their guest said there was absolutely no need for a young child to have a phone/tablet, and they should only get one when around 13.

Home

Johannesburg based attorney specializing in personal injury matters including Road Accident Fund claims and medical negligence matters. My interests include golf, reading and the internet and the way it is constantly developing. I have a passion for life and a desire for less stress!
Have you been injured in a motor accident?


Recent Settlements
Lumbar spine compression fractures R2,500,000.00
Severe hip fracture requiring total hip replacements R3,305,000.00
Head injury with disfiguring facial scaring of a young female R4,000,000.00
Whiplash and compression fracture of the spine R4,000,000.00
Broken Femora R1,914,416.00
Broken Femur and Patella R770,881.15
Loss of Support for two minor children R2,649,968.00
Fracture of the right Humerus, fracture of the pubi rami, abdominal injuries, head injury R4,613,352.95
Fracture of the right femur, Fracture of the right tibia-fibula R1,200,000.00
Broken Jaw, Right Shoulder Injury, Mild head injury R1,100,000.00
Degloving injuries to the hips, legs and ankle R877,773.00
Head injury R2,734,295.12
Fractured pelvis R1,355,881.53
Damaged tendons in left arm R679,688.03
Fractured left hand R692,164.48
Amputated right lower leg with loss of income R3,921,000.00
Fractured left foot R600,000.00
Head injury and multiple facial fractures R5,000,000.00
Head injury, compound fracture right femur, right tib and fib fracture, and injury to the spleen R4,529,672.06
Head injury, multiple facial fractures, collapsed lung and a fracture to the right frontal bone R2,890,592.77
Loss of support R5,144,000.00

 


Archives
August 2023
February 2023
November 2022
August 2022
July 2022
June 2022
February 2022
November 2021
October 2021
September 2021

Privacy Policy



Johannesburg Web Design South Africa